Guide

Unapproved and unpriced change orders in the WIP schedule

The client said yes on site but nothing is signed. Here is how that change order should show up in cost, contract price and over or under billing.

Short answer: Put change order cost into cost to date when you incur it. Add revenue for the change only once the client has approved the scope, and then only the amount you are confident will not be reversed. If the scope is not approved, leave the contract price alone, so the house's margin drops until the change is signed.

Want a WIP schedule your lender trusts? Our team builds it every month. Request a Relationship Assessment.

Three kinds of change orders

A CFMA article by a construction CPA sorts change orders into three groups, and each one lands on the WIP schedule differently.

TypeScope agreed?Price agreed?Contract price on WIPEstimated total cost on WIP
ApprovedYesYesAdd the signed amountAdd the estimated cost
Approved, unpricedYesNot yetAdd an estimate only if recovery is probable, often limited to cost until the price is settledAdd the estimated cost
UnapprovedNoNoLeave unchanged unless recovery is probable after a close lookAdd the estimated cost

The common thread: cost goes in when you spend it. Contract price moves only as far as the approval supports.

What the revenue standard says

If your financial statements follow U.S. GAAP, change orders fall under the contract modification rules in ASC 606. PwC's revenue guide summarizes them this way:

  • Approval can be written, oral or implied by customary business practice, as long as it creates enforceable rights and obligations. Until the change is approved, you keep accounting for the existing contract.
  • Scope agreed, price not agreed is an unpriced change order. You estimate the price change using the variable consideration rules, looking at things like your experience with similar changes.
  • The constraint. ASC 606-10-32-11 lets you include an estimate only to the extent it is probable that a significant reversal of revenue will not occur later. Factors that raise the risk include amounts that depend on someone else's judgment and limited experience with similar contracts.
  • A house is usually one performance obligation. PwC's guide uses a builder example: when a single performance obligation is modified partway through, you update the price and the percent complete, and the effect is a cumulative catch-up in that period.

A verbal yes from a client on site may or may not be enforceable. That is a contract question, not an accounting one, and it is the best reason to get every change signed before the work starts.

A worked example (made-up numbers)

A custom home has a $900,000 fixed-price contract and an original estimated cost of $765,000, a 15 percent margin. The client asked on site for upgraded windows. Your cost is $18,000, already spent, and you plan to charge $22,000. Cost to date including the windows is $459,000. The revised estimated total cost is $783,000, so the house is 58.6 percent complete. You have billed $520,000.

Unapproved: no price changeScope approved, priced at costSigned at $22,000
Contract price$900,000$918,000$922,000
Estimated total cost$783,000$783,000$783,000
Estimated gross profit$117,000 (13.0%)$135,000 (14.7%)$139,000 (15.1%)
Earned to date at 58.6%$527,586$538,138$540,483
Billed to date$520,000$520,000$520,000
Under billed$7,586$18,138$20,483

Percent complete is $459,000 divided by $783,000. Earned to date is the contract price times that percentage, rounded to the dollar. The middle column follows the CFMA approach for a change you expect to recover at more than cost: raise the contract price only by the cost until the price is resolved, and recognize the profit later. The left column shows why an unsigned change hurts: you carry the full cost with no matching revenue, so the margin on the house fades by two points this month.

Why lenders care

The CFMA article notes that banks and sureties look hard at unapproved change orders and often take a conservative view until they are agreed in writing. If your WIP schedule counts unsigned changes in the contract price and the lender takes them out, your under billings and equity shrink in their eyes, along with your credibility. A WIP schedule that shows each change order's status lets the lender see exactly what is signed and what is not. See what a bank asks for at line renewal.

A monthly routine

  1. Log every change in the field the day it is asked for, with the cost code and an estimate. See change order tracking.
  2. Mark a status on each: signed, scope approved but unpriced, or unapproved.
  3. Put all change order cost into cost to date and estimated total cost, whatever the status, so percent complete is honest.
  4. Move contract price only for signed changes, and for unpriced changes only as far as your CPA agrees recovery is probable.
  5. Review anything unsigned for more than 30 days in the monthly WIP review, and decide whether to chase the signature or accept the cost.
  6. Price the change properly before work starts. See how to price a change order.

Cost-plus jobs and other methods

On a cost-plus contract, extra work usually flows into billing as cost plus your fee, so the gap is smaller, but the client still has to agree the work is in scope. If your CPA prepares statements on a tax basis or uses the completed contract method, the treatment can differ. See percentage of completion vs completed contract and take this page to your CPA. We do not give tax advice.

New to WIP? Start with what a WIP schedule is and over and under billing, or try the free WIP schedule template.

How we help

Our team builds your WIP schedule every month with each change order's status shown, so you and your lender see what is signed, what is pending and what it does to margin. Our founder reviews every close. We quote a flat monthly price for each builder, starting at $1,500 a month, with typical engagements between $2,500 and $8,500 a month. Start with a $1,500 Margin Review for written findings. See job costing, construction bookkeeping, pricing or request a Relationship Assessment.

Sources

Common questions

How do unapproved change orders affect the WIP schedule?

Their cost goes into cost to date and estimated total cost right away, but the contract price stays the same unless recovery is probable. The house's margin drops until the change is signed.

What is an unpriced change order?

A change where the client has approved the scope but the price has not been agreed. Under ASC 606 you estimate the price change and include only the amount that is unlikely to be reversed.

Does a verbal approval count?

Under ASC 606 approval can be written, oral or implied by customary practice if it creates enforceable rights. Whether a verbal yes is enforceable is a contract question, so get changes signed.

Should I include profit on an unpriced change order?

A common conservative approach is to raise the contract price only by the cost until the price is settled, then recognize the profit once it is agreed. Confirm your policy with your CPA.

Why does my lender remove change orders from my WIP?

Banks and sureties often take a conservative view of changes not agreed in writing. Showing each change order's status on the WIP schedule makes that review easier.

Can you build our WIP schedule with change order status?

Yes. We build the WIP schedule monthly with every change order marked signed, unpriced or unapproved.

Related

By John Mos, Founder. Updated . We do not give tax or legal advice. Please ask your CPA or attorney.

See where your margin goes, house by house.

Tell us about your homes and your books. If we are a fit, we start with a $1,500 Margin Review: written findings and a fixed quote in 10 business days, credited to your onboarding fee if you sign up.