Percentage of completion vs completed contract for home builders
When a custom home's revenue shows up in your books, and why it matters.
Short answer: Percentage of completion books revenue as each house is built, usually by cost to date divided by estimated total cost. Completed contract books nothing until the house is finished. For monthly management books, percentage of completion shows real margin by house. Home construction contracts are exempt from the tax rule requiring it, so your CPA picks the tax method separately.
What is percent complete in construction accounting?
Percent complete is cost to date divided by current estimated total cost. Multiply it by the contract price to get revenue earned to date, then compare that with billings. It measures progress by cost incurred, not by invoices sent or how much of the draw schedule has been paid.
| Item | Formula | Made-up example |
|---|---|---|
| Estimated total cost | Current best estimate for the house | $496,000 |
| Cost to date | From the job cost report | $248,000 |
| Percent complete | Cost to date / estimated total cost | 50% |
| Revenue earned | Contract price x percent complete | $620,000 x 50% = $310,000 |
| Profit earned to date | Revenue earned minus cost to date | $310,000 - $248,000 = $62,000 |
Made-up numbers for illustration. The estimated total cost must be updated for approved change orders and known overruns.
Two ways to answer one question
Every builder has to decide when the revenue on a house counts as earned. On a 10-month custom home, that choice decides whether your profit and loss shows steady margin each month or long stretches of nothing followed by one big month at closing. It also decides whether your lender, bonding agent or buyer of your company can read your numbers without a long explanation.
- Percentage of completion. Revenue is recognized as the work is done. The most common measure is cost to cost: costs incurred to date divided by total estimated costs, applied to the contract price. The gap between what you earned and what you billed shows up on the balance sheet as over billing or under billing.
- Completed contract. Costs build up on the balance sheet as construction in progress, billings build up as a liability, and nothing hits revenue or job cost on the P&L until the house is complete.
This guide is about your books: the monthly numbers you run the company on. The tax method is a separate decision, covered briefly below, and it belongs to your CPA.
SAMPLE math (made-up numbers)
SAMPLE only. A custom home has a $900,000 contract and $750,000 of estimated total cost. At the end of month five, $300,000 of cost is in. Percent complete is $300,000 divided by $750,000, or 40%. Earned revenue is 40% of $900,000, or $360,000, and gross profit to date is $60,000. If you have billed $400,000 in draws, you are over billed by $40,000, which sits as a liability until the work catches up. Under completed contract, the same month shows $0 of revenue and $0 of job cost for this house, with $300,000 sitting in construction in progress and $400,000 in billings on the balance sheet. This SAMPLE is not a market claim.
Want your CPA's method applied correctly in your WIP? Request a Relationship Assessment.
Why percentage of completion is the better management view
- Margin shows up while you can still fix it. If estimated total cost on that SAMPLE house rises to $800,000, percent complete and margin drop that month, not at closing. Our WIP schedule guide walks through the monthly report that does this for every open house.
- The P&L stops swinging. With 3 to 15 homes a year, a few closings in one quarter can make a completed contract P&L look like a great year followed by a bad one, even when nothing changed in the field. See reading a builder P&L.
- Over billing becomes visible. Front-loaded draws feel like cash, but they are money you still owe in work. Tracking it is the core of WIP over and under billing.
The tradeoff is that percentage of completion is only as good as your estimate of total cost. That means a current budget with approved change orders, committed costs from purchase orders, and an honest cost to complete. If those are stale, the revenue number is wrong too.
What GAAP says, in plain words
If your statements need to follow US GAAP, for example for a lender that asks for reviewed or audited financials, revenue falls under ASC 606. That standard recognizes revenue over time when one of three tests is met, including when the customer controls the asset as it is created. A custom home built on the client's own lot often fits that test, so it is usually measured over time with a method like cost to cost. A spec home is different: you own the lot and the house until a buyer closes, so revenue is typically recognized at closing. Your CPA makes the final call for your contracts.
ASC 606 also adjusts the cost-to-cost measure in two cases builders run into. Costs from significant waste or rework that were not priced into the contract should not push percent complete up. Expensive materials delivered before they are installed, such as a large cabinet or window package, may be excluded from the percent complete measure and recognized at zero margin until they go in. PwC's guidance for construction contractors covers that uninstalled materials adjustment in detail.
The tax side, briefly
We do not give tax advice, so this is only a pointer. Section 460 of the tax code generally requires percentage of completion for long-term construction contracts. Home construction contracts are exempt. Treasury regulations define one as a contract where at least 80% of the estimated costs relate to dwelling units in buildings with four or fewer units, plus related site improvements. The IRS notes these contracts are also exempt from the look-back interest rules. Exempt methods commonly used include completed contract and the accrual method. Many builders keep percentage of completion in their monthly books and file taxes on a different method. That is normal, as long as your CPA has a clean way to get from one to the other at year end.
How we set it up in QuickBooks Online
- Each house is a project, with costs coded to the house and cost code. See how to job cost a custom home.
- Draws are invoiced to the project as they are billed, so billings to date are always on the books.
- Each month we update estimated total cost from the budget, approved change orders and committed costs, calculate percent complete, and post one over or under billing entry. The entry reverses the next month, so the house always shows the current position.
- The WIP schedule ties to the balance sheet. If they disagree, we find out why before the close is done.
How we help
Our team closes your books each month and, on Builder Controller, prepares a monthly WIP schedule with percent complete, earned revenue and over or under billing for every open house. Our founder reviews every close. Builder Controller adds WIP and a 13-week cash forecast. Builder Books is our core monthly job-cost service. We quote a flat monthly price for each builder. Start with a $1,500 Margin Review for written findings. See WIP schedules, fractional controller, pricing or request a Relationship Assessment.
Sources
- Procore, The Percentage of Completion Method Explained
- Legal Information Institute, 26 CFR 1.460-3, Long-term construction contracts
- IRS, Examination and closing procedures: Form 8697, Look-Back Interest
- IRS, Construction Industry Audit Technique Guide
- Federal Register, Rules for Home Construction Contracts (2008)
- FASB, Revenue from Contracts with Customers (Topic 606)
- PwC Viewpoint, Uninstalled materials (revenue recognition guide)
- Modus, Percentage-of-Completion Accounting for Contractors
Common questions
Can a custom home builder use completed contract?
For taxes, home construction contracts are exempt from the rule that requires percentage of completion, so completed contract is often available. Your CPA decides. For monthly management books, percentage of completion usually gives a truer view.
Is percentage of completion the same as a WIP schedule?
The WIP schedule is the monthly report that applies percentage of completion to every open house and shows earned revenue and over or under billing.
How is percent complete measured?
Most builders use cost to cost: costs to date divided by estimated total cost. It only works if the budget, change orders and committed costs are current.
How are spec homes handled?
A spec home is usually recognized when the buyer closes, because you own the house until then. Costs sit in inventory until the sale.
Do you file taxes on either method?
No. We do not file taxes or give tax advice. We keep your monthly books and hand your CPA clean year-end numbers.
What is percent complete in construction accounting?
Percent complete is cost to date divided by current estimated total cost. Multiply it by the contract price to get revenue earned to date, then compare that with billings. It measures progress by cost incurred, not by invoices sent or how much of the draw schedule has been paid.
Related
- What is a WIP schedule?
- WIP over and under billing
- Cost-plus vs fixed-price accounting
- Spec home accounting
- WIP schedules
- Glossary: Percentage of completion
- Glossary: Cost-to-cost method
- Glossary: Completed contract method
- Request a Relationship Assessment
- WIP schedule example for a custom home builder
- Cash vs accrual accounting for home builders
By John Mos, Founder. Updated . We do not give tax or legal advice. Please ask your CPA or attorney.
See where your margin goes, house by house.
Tell us about your homes and your books. If we are a fit, we start with a $1,500 Margin Review: written findings and a fixed quote in 10 business days, credited to your onboarding fee if you sign up.