Cash vs accrual accounting for home builders: keep the books you manage by, let your CPA pick the tax method
Why job cost by house needs accrual-style books even when your tax return uses the cash method, and what to ask your CPA.
Short answer: For a home builder, the books you manage by and the method on your tax return can be different. Job costing by house needs accrual-style books: bills recorded when received, invoices recorded when billed, and costs matched to the house they belong to. The tax method is a separate decision. Many small builders may use the cash method for tax if they meet the IRS gross receipts test, and home construction contracts have their own exception from percentage of completion. Your CPA decides.
Should a home builder use cash or accrual accounting?
To manage the business, use accrual-style books so each cost lands on the house it belongs to when it is incurred. The tax method is a separate decision made with a CPA. Many small builders qualify for the cash method for tax under the IRS gross receipts test, and home construction contracts have their own exception from percentage of completion.
| Question | Cash basis | Accrual basis |
|---|---|---|
| When a vendor bill is recorded | When it is paid | When it is received |
| When an invoice is recorded | When it is collected | When it is billed |
| Job cost by house | Costs follow payment dates, so a house can look better than it is | Costs match the house they belong to |
| WIP and over or under billing | Hard to produce reliably | Can be produced from the books |
| Tax return method | Allowed for some small taxpayers | Your CPA decides |
Two different questions
Builders often ask one question, "cash or accrual?", when there are two. How should my books be kept so I can see what each house is making? And which method does my tax return use? They can have different answers. Mixing them up is how builders end up with books that satisfy the tax return and tell them nothing about margin.
The methods in plain terms
| Cash | Accrual | Hybrid | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Income is recorded | When money is received | When earned or billed | Any consistent mix that clearly reflects income |
| Expenses are recorded | When paid | When incurred, such as when a sub bill is received | Same |
| Strength | Simple, follows the bank | Matches cost to the house and the month | Flexible |
| Problem for a builder | Costs and draws land in the wrong month, so house margin is distorted | More entries to keep current | Easy to be inconsistent |
The IRS describes these in Publication 538. Under an accrual method you generally report income in the year it is earned and deduct or capitalize expenses in the year incurred, which is the point of matching income and expenses. Under the cash method you report when you receive or pay.
Want your books on the right basis for your lender and CPA? Request a Relationship Assessment.
Why job costing needs accrual-style books
Take a framing sub who finishes House A in October and is paid in November. On a cash basis the cost shows up in November, possibly on the wrong house if the check is coded loosely. A $140,000 lender draw received in October looks like October revenue even if the work covered by it spans three months. Neither number tells you what House A earned in October.
Accrual-style books fix that with four habits: enter sub and vendor bills in accounts payable when they arrive, invoice or record revenue when billed, hold retainage and deposits on the balance sheet, and code every line to a house and cost code. A WIP schedule then converts billings to revenue earned. You can do all of this in QuickBooks Online and still hand your CPA what they need.
What the tax rules allow, and why you should ask
These are the rules as the sources below describe them. They change, and they depend on your entity, so treat this as a list of questions for your CPA, not advice.
- Cash method eligibility. Pub. 538 says a corporation or partnership that is not a tax shelter and meets the gross receipts test can generally use the cash method. The test uses average annual gross receipts for the three prior tax years. The threshold is indexed for inflation, and tax publications put it at $32 million for tax years beginning in 2026.
- Inventory. A business that must account for inventory generally uses accrual for purchases and sales, but small business taxpayers can choose not to keep an inventory and instead use a method such as treating materials as non-incidental materials and supplies.
- Long-term contracts. Section 460 generally requires percentage of completion for long-term contracts, with exceptions. Residential and home construction contracts are in the exception, subject to the 80 percent of estimated cost test. A 2025 law change widened the home construction exception beyond buildings of four or fewer units for contracts entered into in tax years beginning after July 4, 2025.
So a small custom builder may well file on the cash method or a completed-contract approach for tax while keeping accrual-style books and a WIP schedule to run the business. That is a normal combination. Whether it is right for you is a question about your entity, your gross receipts and your contracts.
Setting this up in QuickBooks Online
- Enter vendor and sub bills as bills when received, not as checks when paid. Use the bill date and pay later.
- Run reports on the accrual basis for management, and let your CPA run cash where needed. QuickBooks lets you switch the report basis.
- Record customer billings as invoices, and keep retainage and deposits on the balance sheet. See our guides on retainage and customer deposits.
- Close each month and book the WIP adjustment, so revenue follows the work, not the bank.
- Ask your CPA to use the same ledger for the return and to book any tax-basis adjustments themselves.
Questions to bring to your CPA
- Which method do I use for tax today, and does my gross receipts history change that?
- Do my contracts qualify as home construction contracts?
- How should spec homes be treated, since there may be no customer contract until sale?
- Can you use my accrual-basis books and make the tax adjustments?
We do not give tax or legal advice. This page is to help you ask better questions.
How we help
Our team keeps your books accrual-style by house and cost code, so your CPA gets clean records and you get a margin you can trust. Our founder reviews every close. We quote a flat monthly price for each builder, starting at $1,500 a month, with typical engagements between $2,500 and $8,500 a month. Start with a $1,500 Margin Review for written findings. See job costing, construction bookkeeping, pricing or request a Relationship Assessment.
Sources
- Procore, Accrual vs. Cash Accounting in Construction
- IRS, Publication 538, Accounting Periods and Methods
- 26 U.S. Code ยง 460, Special rules for long-term contracts (U.S. House Office of the Law Revision Counsel)
- Peters Bandura, Residential Construction Contract in 2026 (Oct 22, 2026)
- Federal Register, Small Business Taxpayer Exceptions Under Sections 263A, 448, 460 and 471
Common questions
Should a home builder use cash or accrual accounting?
For managing the business and job costing, accrual-style books work better because they match costs and revenue to the house and month. The tax method is a separate decision your CPA makes.
Can a home builder use the cash method for taxes?
Many small builders may, if they meet the IRS gross receipts test and are not a tax shelter. Eligibility depends on your entity and your three-year average gross receipts, so confirm with your CPA.
What is the gross receipts threshold for the cash method in 2026?
Tax publications put it at $32 million of average annual gross receipts for the three prior tax years, for tax years beginning in 2026. It is indexed for inflation.
Do home construction contracts have to use percentage of completion?
Under section 460, home and residential construction contracts are within an exception, subject to a test that at least 80 percent of estimated costs relate to dwelling units and related site improvements. Ask your CPA how it applies.
Can I keep accrual books and file a cash-basis return?
Yes. Many builders keep accrual-style books for management and have their CPA make the tax-basis adjustments.
How do I switch QuickBooks Online reports between cash and accrual?
On most reports you can change the report basis in the customize options. Bills must be entered when received for accrual reports to be meaningful.
Related
- Percentage of completion vs completed contract
- What is a WIP schedule?
- Month-end close checklist for builders
- Retainage and customer deposits
- Construction bookkeeper vs a generalist CPA
- Year-end close and CPA handoff checklist for home builders
- Glossary: Accrual method
- Glossary: Cash method
By John Mos, Founder. Updated . We do not give tax or legal advice. Please ask your CPA or attorney.
See where your margin goes, house by house.
Tell us about your homes and your books. If we are a fit, we start with a $1,500 Margin Review: written findings and a fixed quote in 10 business days, credited to your onboarding fee if you sign up.