Guide

Job costing a remodel vs a custom home: what changes in the books

Same cost codes, different rhythm. How job length, change volume, billing and overhead differ, and what to adjust if you do both.

Short answer: A remodel and a custom home use the same job cost idea, every cost coded to a job and cost code, but the rhythm differs. Remodels are shorter and more numerous, so overhead per job and change order discipline matter more, and hidden conditions drive variance. Custom homes run for many months, so WIP, draws and cost-to-complete forecasting matter more. If you do both, separate them with a class or a job type and keep one chart of accounts.

Where the two diverge

RemodelCustom home
Typical durationWeeks to a few monthsMany months to a year or more
Number of jobs open at onceOften manyOften a handful
Biggest variance driverHidden conditions found after demolition, scope that growsSelections and allowances, long-lead items, cost drift over time
Contract typeFixed price, time and materials or cost-plusFixed price or cost-plus, often with allowances
BillingDeposit, then milestone or weekly or monthly progressDraw schedule, often tied to a lender's draws
What management needs mostChange order discipline, quick close-out, estimate accuracy by tradeWIP, cost to complete, draw packages, cash by house
Overhead per jobA larger share of each job, because sales and estimating effort is spread over smaller contractsA smaller share of each job

What changes in the books

Change orders carry the margin on remodels

Remodels see more change orders per dollar of contract, and the work is often done before the paperwork. Track each change as a line with its own price and cost, and reconcile the change log to invoices before you close a job. Our guides on change order tracking and pricing a change order apply directly.

Hidden conditions need a contingency, and a place to record it

If you carry a contingency, decide how it is tracked and released. See contingency tracking. Do not bury it inside other cost codes, or you will not see how often it is consumed.

Short jobs make a WIP schedule less useful and a close-out checklist more useful

A job that starts and finishes inside a month or two may never appear on a month-end WIP at a meaningful percent complete. The discipline is a fast close-out: final bills in, final invoice out, retainage and deposits cleared, margin compared to the estimate. See closing out a job.

Cost-plus and time and materials need clean billable costs

If you bill costs plus a fee, every bill must be coded to the right job promptly, because the invoice is built from the job's costs. See cost-plus vs fixed-price accounting.

Custom homes need the long view

Draws, retainage, allowances and a monthly cost-to-complete forecast carry the weight. See WIP schedules and cost-to-complete forecasting.

Building custom homes? We set up job costing built for them. Request a Relationship Assessment.

If you do both: a practical setup

  1. One chart of accounts and one cost code list. Remodel jobs use a subset. Do not fork the structure, or you cannot compare them.
  2. Tag the job type. Use a class such as Remodel and Custom, or a naming prefix on the project. A Profit and Loss by Class then shows each line of business. See our classes vs projects guide.
  3. Allocate overhead on a basis that fits both. A flat percent of revenue may overcharge the larger custom jobs and undercharge the smaller remodels. See overhead allocation.
  4. Report each type on its own rhythm. A weekly open-jobs review for remodels. A monthly WIP and cost-to-complete review for custom homes.

A note on tax method

Section 460 treats contracts for the construction, reconstruction or rehabilitation of dwelling units under its home construction rules, so a remodel of a home may fall within the same exception as a new house, subject to the 80 percent of estimated cost test. Whether a given job qualifies is a question for your CPA. This is not tax advice.

How we help

Our team keeps remodel and custom jobs on one chart of accounts, tags each type and reports each on the rhythm that fits it. Our founder reviews every close. We quote a flat monthly price for each builder, starting at $1,500 a month, with typical engagements between $2,500 and $8,500 a month. Start with a $1,500 Margin Review for written findings. See job costing, construction bookkeeping, pricing or request a Relationship Assessment.

Sources

Common questions

Is job costing different for remodels and custom homes?

The method is the same, every cost coded to a job and cost code. The emphasis differs: remodels need change order discipline and fast close-outs, custom homes need WIP, draws and cost-to-complete forecasts.

Should I use the same cost codes for remodels and new homes?

Yes. Use one cost code list and let remodel jobs use a subset, so you can compare jobs.

How do I separate remodel and custom profit in QuickBooks Online?

Tag each job with a class or a naming convention, then run Profit and Loss by Class for the line-of-business view and project reports for the job view.

Do remodels need a WIP schedule?

If jobs run across month-ends, yes. For very short jobs a fast close-out checklist is often more useful.

Why is overhead heavier on remodels?

Sales, estimating and administration effort is spread over smaller contracts, so overhead is often a larger share of each job.

Can you set up job costing for both types of work?

Yes. Our team sets up one structure and reports each type on its own rhythm.

Related

By John Mos, Founder. Updated . We do not give tax or legal advice. Please ask your CPA or attorney.

See where your margin goes, house by house.

Tell us about your homes and your books. If we are a fit, we start with a $1,500 Margin Review: written findings and a fixed quote in 10 business days, credited to your onboarding fee if you sign up.