Guide

Subcontractor backcharges and supplier returns in QuickBooks Online

How to record a backcharge or a material return so the cost lands on the right house, the sub's balance is right and nothing gets counted twice.

Short answer: Record a backcharge as a vendor credit to the subcontractor who caused the cost, tagged to the same house and cost code as the repair, then apply it in Pay bills against that sub's next bill or retainage. Supplier returns work the same way. The repair cost stays on the house and the credit offsets it.

Want backcharges and returns posted to the right house every month? Our team does it as part of the close. Request a Relationship Assessment.

Why short-paying the bill is the wrong fix

The quick way to handle a backcharge is to pay the sub less than the bill and move on. In QuickBooks Online that leaves a problem behind. The bill still shows an open balance, so accounts payable is overstated and the sub looks unpaid. The repair you paid another trade sits on the house at full cost with nothing against it, so the job looks worse than it is. And there is no record of why the payment was short, which is what you need when the sub disputes it or when you collect a lien waiver.

A vendor credit fixes all three. It reduces what you owe that sub, it carries the house and cost code, and it leaves a dated record you can attach backup to.

What counts as a backcharge

A backcharge is a cost you charge back to a subcontractor or supplier because of their work: defective work, defective materials, damage on the job, cleanup they skipped or use of your equipment. Levelset notes that backcharges are not set by statute. They come from the contract, so if the subcontract does not allow them, you may not be able to take one. Procore describes them as an adjustment to the sub's contract value rather than a separate cash payment: the responsible sub's contract goes down by what you spent to fix the problem.

The subcontract also decides notice, the time the sub has to fix the work first and whether you can add a markup. We do not give legal advice, so check those terms with your attorney. This guide covers the books once you have decided to take the backcharge.

Where each situation goes in QuickBooks Online

SituationWhat to enterWhere the cost lands
Sub damaged another trade's work and you paid that trade to repair itBill from the repairing trade, then a vendor credit to the responsible subBoth on the same house and the same rework or repair cost code, so they net to zero when fully recovered
Sub skipped cleanup and your crew did itCrew time to the house as usual, then a vendor credit to the sub for the agreed amountCredit on the cleanup cost code where the labor landed
Unused material returned to the supplier, bill not yet paidVendor credit to the supplierSame house and cost code as the original bill
Return refunded by check on a bill you already paidVendor credit, then a bank deposit to Accounts Payable linked in Pay billsSame house and cost code as the original bill
Return refunded to a credit cardCredit card creditSame category as the original charge, tagged to the house
Restocking fee kept by the supplierLeave it on the original billStays as a cost of that house

The refund steps follow Intuit's help article on vendor credits and refunds. If the material is moving to another house rather than back to the supplier, it is not a return. Move the cost from one house to the other instead.

Step by step: the vendor credit

  1. Select + Create, then Vendor credit, and pick the subcontractor or supplier.
  2. In Category details, use the same job cost account and cost code you would use for the repair or the original purchase.
  3. In the Customer/Project column, pick the house. An Intuit team reply in the QuickBooks Community confirms a vendor credit can carry a project and then shows on that project's Transactions tab.
  4. Describe it in plain words, such as "Backcharge: drywall repair after rough electrical, lot 14," and attach the notice, photos and the repair invoice.
  5. Save and close.

Applying the credit

Go to Pay bills and select that vendor's next bill. Intuit says QuickBooks applies available credits automatically, so check the Credit Applied amount before you save. You can apply part of a credit, and a credit applied to one bill is no longer available for the others. If the credit covers the whole bill, QuickBooks records a $0 payment and marks the bill paid without moving money.

If the sub has no more bills coming, apply the credit against the bill that releases their retainage. See retainage in QuickBooks Online. If they owe you more than you will ever pay them, the credit sits open on their balance until they pay you or you write it off with your CPA's input.

A worked example (made-up numbers)

The electrician's subcontract on a house is $18,000. After rough-in, a wall had to be opened to fix a wiring fault, and you paid the drywall sub $650 to patch and refinish it. The subcontract allows the backcharge and the electrician agreed to it.

EntryVendorCost codeAmount
Bill for the drywall repairDrywall subRework and repairs$650
Vendor credit (backcharge)ElectricianRework and repairs($650)
Electrician's next billElectricianElectrical$6,000
Paid in Pay bills after the creditElectrician$5,350

The math checks: $6,000 less the $650 credit is $5,350. On the job cost report, the rework line nets to $0 and electrical stays on budget at what you actually owe. In your project software, reduce the electrician's purchase order or commitment by $650 to $17,350 so committed cost and cost to complete stay right. See purchase orders and committed costs.

Some builders code the credit to the responsible trade's cost code instead. Either works if you pick one and use it every time. A single rework code has one advantage: it shows how much rework you are carrying across all houses, and how much of it you recovered.

When the sub disputes it

Record the repair cost when you incur it, because it is a real cost of the house either way. Enter the vendor credit once the backcharge is agreed, or once you have issued it under the subcontract with its backup. Keep disputed amounts on a short list you review at month end. Levelset points out that a sub who disputes a backcharge may still claim the full amount, including through a lien, so make sure the lien waiver you collect matches what you actually paid and ask your attorney about the wording. Ask your CPA how backcharges affect the amounts you report for that sub at year end.

A monthly check

  • Run the vendor balance detail report and look for credits that were never applied.
  • Compare each sub's commitment in your project software with their bills less credits in QuickBooks.
  • Review the rework cost code by house. Large unrecovered amounts are a margin problem worth a conversation.
  • Tie out the job cost report to the profit and loss. See tying out Buildertrend or JobTread to QuickBooks Online.

For the full picture of how each cost reaches the right house, start with how to job cost a custom home and our accounts payable workflow.

How we help

Our team enters backcharges, returns and refunds against the right house and cost code, applies credits when bills are paid and reviews open credits at every close. Our founder reviews every close. We quote a flat monthly price for each builder, starting at $1,500 a month, with typical engagements between $2,500 and $8,500 a month. Start with a $1,500 Margin Review for written findings. See job costing, construction bookkeeping, pricing or request a Relationship Assessment.

Sources

Common questions

How do I record a backcharge to a subcontractor in QuickBooks Online?

Create a vendor credit to that sub, use the same job cost account and cost code as the repair, pick the house in the Customer/Project column and attach the backup. Then apply it in Pay bills against their next bill.

Should I just pay the sub less than their bill?

No. Short-paying leaves an open balance on the bill, overstates what you owe and leaves no record of why. A vendor credit keeps payables and the job cost report right.

Which cost code should a backcharge credit use?

Use the same code as the repair cost so the two net to zero, often a rework and repairs code. Coding it to the responsible trade also works if you do it the same way every time.

How do I record a refund check from a supplier for a bill I already paid?

Enter a vendor credit, deposit the check to Accounts Payable with the supplier as the payee, then link the two in Pay bills so the payment shows $0.

What if the sub has no more bills?

Apply the credit to the bill that releases their retainage. If nothing is left to pay, the credit stays on their balance until it is settled.

Can you handle backcharges and returns for us?

Yes. We post them to the right house and cost code, apply credits when bills are paid and review open credits every month.

Related

By John Mos, Founder. Updated . We do not give tax or legal advice. Please ask your CPA or attorney.

See where your margin goes, house by house.

Tell us about your homes and your books. If we are a fit, we start with a $1,500 Margin Review: written findings and a fixed quote in 10 business days, credited to your onboarding fee if you sign up.