Progress billing vs the lender draw: keeping them aligned
Your invoice to the client, the lender's draw request and your WIP schedule are three different documents. Here is how to keep them from drifting apart.
Short answer: A progress invoice bills the client for work completed under the contract. A lender draw request asks the lender to release loan money against the lender's budget lines. WIP compares what you have billed with what you have earned. They use different line items and sometimes different percentages, so keep one contract schedule of values, map it once to the lender budget, and reconcile billed to date, drawn to date and earned to date every month.
Want invoices, draws and WIP tied out every month? Our team does the reconciliation. Request a Relationship Assessment.
Three documents, three jobs
| Progress invoice | Lender draw request | WIP schedule | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | What does the client owe for work done? | How much loan money is released now? | Have we billed more or less than we earned? |
| Built from | Contract schedule of values or payment schedule | Lender's approved budget lines | Contract, change orders and cost to complete |
| Checked by | The client | Lender, often with an inspector | You, your CPA and your lender |
| Software | Buildertrend or JobTread invoices | Lender's form or an AIA-style G702 and G703 | Your WIP report. See the WIP template. |
What Buildertrend and JobTread each produce
Buildertrend's help center says fixed-price jobs can carry a payment schedule that divides the contract into draws by percentage and creates draft invoices, and its invoice marketing page describes progress invoices that organize the schedule of values into line-item summaries of work completed, billed and remaining. JobTread's invoicing features include payment schedules that generate and send invoices, and its document model separates a Deposit, which collects money before the work it covers is done, from a Customer Invoice, which bills for work already completed. Both sync invoices to QuickBooks Online. Neither document is the lender's draw request, which still follows the lender's form and budget lines.
Where they drift apart
- Different line items. Contract lines are by scope. Lender lines are by the bank's budget categories. Map them once. See lender draw budget vs job budget.
- Different percentages. A payment schedule bills by milestone. An inspector confirms percent complete by line. WIP uses cost-based progress. They rarely match exactly.
- Retainage. A lender or contract may hold back part of each payment. Billed and collected differ until it is released. See retainage and customer deposits.
- Deposits. Money received before work is billed is a liability, not revenue. See deposits and prepayments.
- Change orders. They must reach the contract, the invoice and the lender budget. See change order tracking.
An illustrative example
A custom home has an $800,000 contract. Draw 3 on the payment schedule is 15 percent, or $120,000. If the contract or lender holds 10 percent retainage, $12,000 is held and $108,000 is paid now.
| Measure | Amount |
|---|---|
| Billed to date after draw 3 (cumulative, illustrative) | $360,000 |
| Retainage held to date at 10 percent | $36,000 |
| Cash received to date | $324,000 |
| Earned to date by cost progress (illustrative) | $332,000 |
| Over or (under) billed | $28,000 |
All numbers are made up and checked: $360,000 less $36,000 is $324,000, and $360,000 less $332,000 is $28,000 overbilled. The lender draw may be a different number again, because it is measured against bank budget lines. The point is that all three sit on one house and each one explains the gap to the others. See WIP over and under billing.
Who is the borrower?
On a custom home the client often borrows, and the builder invoices the client while the lender funds the client's account against draw requests. On a spec house the builder is the borrower, so there is no client invoice and loan draws are financing, not revenue. See the construction loan draw process and spec home inventory. Your lender and contract decide who submits what.
A monthly reconciliation
- List billed to date, retainage held, cash received and loan funded to date for each house.
- Compare billed to date with the contract plus approved change orders.
- Compare funded to date with the lender's remaining budget.
- Compare billed with earned in the WIP schedule.
- Explain every difference in one line, and clear anything older than one draw.
See the draw package checklist for what goes to the lender.
How we help
Our team reconciles invoices, draws, retainage and WIP for every house each month, and prepares the draw package from your books. Our founder reviews every close. We quote a flat monthly price for each builder, starting at $1,500 a month, with typical engagements between $2,500 and $8,500 a month. Start with a $1,500 Margin Review for written findings. See job costing, construction bookkeeping, pricing or request a Relationship Assessment.
Sources
- Buildertrend, Invoice management overview (payment schedules on fixed price jobs)
- Buildertrend, Construction invoice software (progress invoices and schedule of values)
- JobTread, Construction invoicing software
- JobTread, Built by Listening (payment schedules)
- OCC, Comptroller's Handbook: Commercial Real Estate Lending
- AIA Contract Documents, FAQs on the G702 and G703
Common questions
What is the difference between progress billing and a draw?
A progress invoice bills the client for work done under the contract. A draw request asks the lender to release loan funds against the lender's budget lines.
Do Buildertrend and JobTread create the lender draw request?
They create invoices and payment schedules. The draw request still follows the lender's form and budget lines, sometimes an AIA-style G702 and G703.
Why do billed, funded and earned amounts differ?
Different line items, different percent-complete methods, retainage and timing.
How do deposits fit in?
Money received before work is billed is a liability until it is applied to billing.
Who is the borrower on a custom home?
Often the client, with the builder invoicing the client. On a spec house the builder is the borrower. Your lender and contract decide.
Can you reconcile this for us each month?
Yes. We reconcile invoices, draws, retainage and WIP by house every month.
Related
- Construction loan draw process
- WIP over and under billing
- Draw package checklist
- Draw schedule template (free)
By John Mos, Founder. Updated . We do not give tax or legal advice. Please ask your CPA or attorney.
See where your margin goes, house by house.
Tell us about your homes and your books. If we are a fit, we start with a $1,500 Margin Review: written findings and a fixed quote in 10 business days, credited to your onboarding fee if you sign up.