Spreadsheets vs QuickBooks vs construction software for builder job costing
Three tools, three jobs. Most builders end up using more than one, and the question is which one holds the official numbers.
Short answer: A spreadsheet is flexible and cheap but easy to break and has no audit trail. QuickBooks Online is the accounting system of record, and its projects show costs and income per house but not commitments, work billed ahead or behind, or a forecast. Construction software such as Buildertrend or JobTread handles estimates, purchase orders, change orders and billing, and syncs to the books. Most builders do best with the books as the official numbers, software for operations and a spreadsheet for the WIP view.
| Spreadsheets | QuickBooks Online | Construction software | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best at | Custom views, WIP, one-off analysis | The accounting record: bills, payments, bank, payroll, financial statements | Estimates, selections, purchase orders, change orders, scheduling, client billing |
| Job cost by house | Manual | Yes, through projects on Plus and Advanced | Yes, from its own transactions |
| Committed costs (open POs and subcontracts) | Manual | Not in project reports. Purchase orders exist but do not show in profitability. | Yes |
| WIP and over/under billing | Yes, if built and maintained | No built-in WIP schedule | Varies by product |
| Audit trail and controls | Weak | Strong | Strong for operations |
| Risk | Formula errors, version drift | Untagged costs, no forecast | Two systems that can disagree |
| Cost | Lowest | Monthly subscription by plan | Monthly subscription by plan |
What each one cannot do
Spreadsheets do not know about your bank or your bills, so numbers are typed or pasted, and a single broken formula can misstate a house for months. QuickBooks Online answers "what has this house cost so far" and not "will it make money". An independent analysis makes that point, and Intuit's own help shows projects tracking income, costs and profit, with estimates versus actuals on Advanced. Construction software manages the job, but Buildertrend and JobTread each describe a QuickBooks Online integration because the accounting still lives in the books. See whether you need QuickBooks with Buildertrend or JobTread.
How the three fit together
- QuickBooks Online is the system of record for money: every bill, payment, invoice and bank line.
- Construction software runs the job and feeds the books through its integration. Keep a monthly tie-out. See how to tie out Buildertrend or JobTread to QuickBooks.
- A spreadsheet or report layer adds the forecast, WIP and KPIs the other two do not. Our free WIP schedule template is a starting point.
Which to start with
- One house at a time, tiny team: QuickBooks with projects and a simple spreadsheet may do.
- Several houses, changes and selections: add construction software, and keep the books as the record.
- A lender, spec inventory or cost-plus billing: add a monthly WIP and tie-out process whichever tools you use.
The tool is not the process
Every combination fails the same way: costs coded to the wrong house, a forecast nobody updates and two systems that nobody reconciles. A good process on a modest stack beats an expensive stack with no process.
Where we fit
Our team works in QuickBooks Online with Buildertrend or JobTread, ties them out each month and builds the WIP and forecast view that the tools do not. Our founder reviews every close. We quote a flat monthly price for each builder, starting at $1,500 a month, with typical engagements between $2,500 and $8,500 a month. Start with a $1,500 Margin Review for written findings. See job costing, construction bookkeeping, pricing or request a Relationship Assessment.
Sources
- Buildertrend, QuickBooks Online integration overview
- JobTread, QuickBooks Online integration
- Intuit, How to set up and use projects in QuickBooks Online
- Navigator, Job costing in QuickBooks Online: what it can and can't tell an owner
- FinTruction, Buildertrend vs QuickBooks: do you need both?
Common questions
Can I do job costing in a spreadsheet?
Yes for a small operation, but it relies on manual entry, has no audit trail and a broken formula can misstate a house. Many builders use a spreadsheet only for the WIP and forecast view.
Is QuickBooks Online enough for job costing?
It shows costs and income per house through projects, but not committed costs, over or under billing or a forecast. Builders usually add a WIP view.
Do I need Buildertrend or JobTread if I have QuickBooks?
They do different jobs. Construction software runs estimates, purchase orders, change orders and client billing, and syncs to the books.
Which system should hold the official numbers?
Most builders keep the accounting system, QuickBooks Online, as the system of record and tie the construction software to it monthly.
Can you work with my tools?
Yes. We work in QuickBooks Online with Buildertrend or JobTread and tie them out every month.
Related
- Accounting software for custom home builders, by fit
- Do home builders need QuickBooks with Buildertrend or JobTread?
- Buildertrend vs JobTread
- QuickBooks Online project profitability report for builders
- QuickBooks Online vs Desktop for home builders
By John Mos, Founder. Updated . We do not give tax or legal advice. Please ask your CPA or attorney.
See where your margin goes, house by house.
Tell us about your homes and your books. If we are a fit, we start with a $1,500 Margin Review: written findings and a fixed quote in 10 business days, credited to your onboarding fee if you sign up.